Last week at Central Market, we introduced our new muffin recipe and flavors. I may be biased, but they are darn good and full of interesting ingredients.
Pear ginger, fig and star anise, banana granola, antioxidant punch (goji, acai, cranberries, and pomegranate), chocolate hazelnut toffee, and strawberry goat cheese to name a few.
We can hardly keep them on the shelves. Let’s just say I have consumed more than my share of muffins this week and any Houstonians out there should come check them out along with all of our other tasty treats!
I absolutely love savory-sweet combinations, so despite swearing off strawberries after the strawberry dipping fest that was Valentine’s Day (I estimate we dipped close to 13,000 strawberries…by hand), the first muffin I dove into was the strawberry goat cheese variety.
Sweet strawberries (and yes we use real fruit in our products) and musky goat cheese play tug-of-war with your senses and eventually meld to create the perfect balance of sweet and savory. Simple ingredients yes, but these are no ordinary muffins.
While I love what we bake at work, I figure if I can bake it on my own, why buy it? So, after dreaming about my new favorite muffin, I decided to give it a whirl at home.
I typically use frozen berries when I bake because they are frozen when perfectly ripe and I think they hold-up much better than fresh fruit during the baking process. This recipe was no exception and I used frozen strawberries, but if you have some fresh strawberries, there is no reason you can’t use them.
The biggest difference between my muffins and those from work, is the addition of fresh thyme, an herb whose woody flavors pair wonderfully not only with savory ingredients but also with sweet, floral berries.
I used a basic muffin batter base from my The America’s Test Kitchen Family Baking Book; the batter is not overly sweet, but is the perfect backdrop for the berries and cheese. If you have a favorite muffin batter, feel free to use that and just use my recommendation for filling measurements.
Strawberry, Goat Cheese, & Thyme Muffins
Makes 12 muffins
Inspired by Central Market. Batter recipe from The America’s Test Kitchen Family Baking Book
Note: Frozen strawberries are ginormous so I chopped them (while still frozen) into bite-sized pieces. This batter yields billowy, tender muffins.
3 cups all purpose flour
1 cup sugar
1 tablespoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon fresh thyme, finely chopped
1 1/2 cups plain yogurt
2 large eggs
8 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and cooled
1 1/2 (about 7 oz) cups roughly chopped frozen strawberries (not thawed)
4 oz fresh goat cheese (no rind), very coarsely crumbled
Preheat oven to 375°F. Grease a 12-cup muffin tin.
Whisk the flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, salt, and thyme together in a large bowl. In a separate bowl, whisk the yogurt and eggs together until smooth. Gently fold yogurt mixture into flour mixture with a rubber spatula until barely combined, then fold in butter, strawberries, and goat cheese until just distributed.
Using a greased 1/3-cup measure, portion the batter into each muffin cup. Bake until golden brown and a toothpick inserted into the center of a muffin comes out with just a few crumbs, 25-30 minutes.
Let muffins cool in the pan for 5 minutes, then remove and cool for 10 minutes on a wire rack before serving.






Yummm. They sound sooo good. You are becoming a wonderful baker.
This sound really good! I love strawberries and goat cheese, I need to do this.
I just tried this recipe out. The muffin ends up a little denser than I am used to, but the result is really good! The thyme and denseness of the muffin give it almost a bready feel to it. It’s delicious and filling! Yum!
Hi! I am glad you gave the recipe a try! I think all the add-ins make these muffins a little heftier for sure, I bet you could bake it in a loaf pan for a nice quick bread.
I just went to Central Market yesterday and tried one of the strawberry goat-cheese muffins and liked it so much I wanted to make some today! I’m so glad I found your recipe because it turned out lovely! I happened to have all the ingredients at my house except enough frozen strawberries, so I supplemented them with blackberries and dark sweet cherries. They still turned out very yummy! Thanks for posting this!
Hi Taylor! I am so glad you liked the muffins at Central Market as well as this recipe! I bet blackberries and cherries would be great; I think goat cheese goes wonderfully with most berries. I would also highly recommend the ginger pear muffins and the chocolate, pistachio, cherry muffins at Central Market.
Have a wonderful day.
I made this today, but I used whole milk in place of the yogurt and rhubarb in place of the strawberries, no thime and they were great, thanks for the recipe!
I love rhubarb! I will have to try that!
I am eating one right now! SO GOOD!
These sound amazing and I would love to try making them. DO you think cranberries could be substituted or would they be too tart? Or maybe raspberries? Only because strawberries aren’t in season right now, I would like to put in a berry that is. Thanks!
Can I substitute coconut flour for the regular flour?
[...] we must all take a break for coffee and a not-so-sweet baked good. Be it cornbread, croissants, muffins, or some form of coffee cake, we all feel much better after we have taken a moment to re-energize [...]
oh god, this looks beyond good!!! I love the strawberry-thyme combo….. and goat cheese just makes this then spectacular
Question: should the yoghurt have some % of fat in it or can I do it with 0% fromage blanc, which I’d have at all times? (yah, I can get that, but no frozen fruit in sight, go figure!) I also like the pear-ginger combination
Might do some half and half baking experimentation…. I shouldn’t be eating so many muffins all by myself…. hahha
Hey
I finally attempted making these, but I adjusted them for the pear and ginger ones. I will do the strawberry ones but for the life of me, I can’t find frozen strawberries & considering how expensive fresh strawberries are, I have a hard time putting them in a cake. Also, if I do use fresh strawberries should I freeze theme before using them in the dough?
I made half the recipe and got 11 muffins. They had lovely tops when they got out of the oven, perfect, like I’ve never achieved & then they collapsed! Also, the muffins are soft, yes, pillowy is the right word, but they’re not crumbly (?!) like a muffin usually is… Is it that I used 0% fat fromage blanc? My goat cheese is like a creamier ricotta & maybe I beat it in too much, I don’t have chunks of it… Maybe the raw pear made it too liquidy…. the batter was quite thick before I added it….
I just hope the strawberry kind works better…
Glad you got a chance to try it! I am not exactly sure what would have caused the muffins to collapse, but it general, I would recommend mixing the batter as little as possible. That would likely help the texture of the muffin as well as keep the goat cheese chunkier. The pears could have been too watery, but when we make them at work, that doesn’t seem to matter too much. I hope you try again and that the strawberry ones turn out well once you are able to find the fruit!
Thank you so much for visiting.
I will definitely let you know how they turn out. It would be interesting to see if it was the pear or the stirring that did it… I couldn’t crumble the cheese, I has to whisk it in unfortunately because I was going to be left with maybe 3-4 giant globs of cheese for the entire batter…